Auditor General: MVR 136 million paid up front for cancelled housing and water projects has not been recovered
An audit of the construction and housing ministry's spending from 2018 to 2023 says 76% of the money paid in advance on 25 cancelled projects was never recovered. It also says re-awarding seven projects cost MVR 112 million more, and a MVR 59 million parking system brought no benefit.
2 sources (1 in Dhivehi)1 outlet5 min read20 views
Written by AI from the sources listed below and reviewed before publication.
This page sums up what two published sources reported. One of them is a Dhivehi report, translated by AI. It is a record of what they say, not original reporting. More on this topic is under Housing.
What did the Auditor General check?
This was a compliance audit. It checks whether money was spent as the budget said and as the public finance law and rules require. The ministry's projects included airports, bridges, harbours, roads, housing, land reclamation, coastal protection, and water and sewerage systems.1
The ministry was created in November 2018 and has changed its name several times. In April 2026 it was renamed from the Ministry of Construction, Housing and Infrastructure.1
How much money paid up front was not recovered?
When the government hires a contractor, it often pays part of the price in advance. By July 2026, 25 projects had been cancelled. The ministry had paid MVR 180.3 million up front on them. Of that, MVR 136.5 million had not come back.1
The ministry told the audit that most contracts were cancelled because government policy changed or contractors performed badly. It had written to some contractors asking for the money back. The audit says the steps in the finance rules were not followed. The rules call for a written reminder within seven days, a second reminder seven days later, and then a court case. The audit found no court case.1
The largest case is a project to build 400 housing units in Kulhudhuffushi. The ministry paid MVR 66.0 million in advance, and MVR 59.2 million (90%) had not been recovered. The contract was cancelled when 18.7% of the work was done. The ministry cited the contractor's poor performance. The unfinished work was handed to the Housing Development Corporation on 26 August 2026. The audit lists the contractor as Dhonbez Private Limited. No response from the company was in the listed sources.1
The audit's list also includes water and sewerage projects on many islands that were given to Fenaka Corporation. See the Fenaka audit story.1
Did moving the projects cost more?
The audit looked at seven projects whose first contractor did not make enough progress. The ministry cancelled the contracts and gave the work to others. Six were water and sewerage projects given to Fenaka Corporation. The audit says the state paid MVR 112.3 million more in total.1
The six water and sewerage projects were first given to Fenaka for MVR 239.0 million. When the contract ended, MVR 56.2 million had been spent. The remaining work went to Malé Water and Sewerage Company for MVR 345.2 million, which is MVR 106.2 million more than the first price. A mosque project in Th. Thinadhoo went from a private company at MVR 3.0 million to the Maldives Transport and Contracting Company at MVR 9.1 million, which is MVR 6.1 million more.1
The audit says this happened because contractors were not properly checked, for money and skills, before they were chosen.1
What happened to the parking system?
In 2016 the ministry began installing automatic parking systems in 20 areas of Malé and Hulhumalé. The audit found no record that a feasibility study was done first.1
The government spent MVR 59.4 million. After the change of government in 2018, the new government did not see the systems as workable, and in 2022 it decided to stop the work. The ministry told the audit on 5 October 2026 that it does not know what happened to the equipment. The audit says no benefit reached the public, and that MVR 13.9 million was paid to a contractor without confirming the work was finished. It asks for an inquiry into whether anyone was negligent.1
Were projects late, and were guarantees still valid?
Of the 634 projects, 161 were not finished by the date in the contract. Some are three or four years late. The ministry gave three reasons: the government paid contractors late, Covid, and a higher US dollar price.1
A contractor's guarantee protects the government if the work fails. On 48 unfinished projects the advance payment guarantee had run out, and on 70 the performance guarantee had run out, by July 2026.1
What about the ministry's records?
The audit says the ministry did not keep full, up-to-date project records. On 12 December 2024 a fire at the ministry building destroyed its server. The audit says there was no backup outside the building, so the financial records could not be recovered.1 The housing minister told state media at the time that most documents and data were lost and the servers were unlikely to survive.2
The ministry told the audit it is now adding its projects to a database made by the Finance Ministry in 2026.1
The audit also found other problems:1
- MVR 77.7 million of regular spending was recorded as capital spending.
- The ministry could not show what became of MVR 11.1 million of materials bought for a 60-unit housing project in Nolhivaranfaru.
What does the Auditor General ask for?
The audit asks the ministry to:1
- follow the finance rules to recover the advance payments, including taking cases to court;
- check that contractors can do the work, in money and skills, before choosing them;
- do a feasibility study before large projects;
- keep contractors' guarantees valid until the work is finished;
- check that work is complete before paying, and examine the parking system spending;
- keep records safe, with a backup in a second place.
What is still unknown
No response from the ministry to the audit beyond the comments in the report was in the listed sources. Whether any money has since been recovered is not stated.
The figures in detail
Money paid in advance on 25 cancelled projects (MVR)
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Advances paid | 180,291,915 |
| Not recovered by July 2026 | 136,533,958 |
| Share not recovered | 76% |
| Kulhudhuffushi, 400 housing units: advance paid | 65,998,674 |
| Kulhudhuffushi: not recovered | 59,221,745 (90%) |
Cost of moving seven projects to new contractors (MVR million)
| First price | New price | Extra | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Six water and sewerage projects | 239.0 | 345.2 | 106.2 |
| Th. Thinadhoo mosque | 3.0 | 9.1 | 6.1 |
| Total extra | 112.3 |
Other figures from the audit
- Projects 2019 to 2023: 634, costing MVR 23.06 billion.1
- Late projects: 161 of 634.1
- Expired guarantees: 48 advance payment guarantees and 70 performance guarantees, by July 2026.1
- Parking system: MVR 59,356,602 spent, of which MVR 13.86 million was paid without confirming the work was finished.1
- Regular spending recorded as capital: MVR 77,745,115.1
- Materials in Nolhivaranfaru with no record: MVR 11,098,379.1
Sources
- Ministry of Infrastructure, Housing and Urban Development 2018-2023, compliance audit (Dhivehi report, dated 9 November 2026) Auditor General's OfficeDhivehi source, translated by AI.Publication by an organisation. Shows what it said or found.
- Housing ministry servers, documents feared lost after fire Atoll Times